Business Stories  →  Brilliant Earth
Brilliant Earth

The Brilliant Earth Story: The Engagement Ring With a Clear Conscience

TransparencyValuesCategory flaw

The company began, fittingly, with an engagement. As co-founder Beth Gerstein told it, shopping for her own ring in the mid-2000s she asked jewellers a simple question — where did this diamond come from? — and discovered that almost nobody could answer. For a purchase meant to symbolize love, the industry's supply chain was a shrug, and headlines about conflict diamonds had given that shrug a dark edge.

Gerstein and her Stanford classmate Eric Grossberg founded Brilliant Earth in 2005 to be the answer: jewellery from traceable, responsibly-sourced origins, recycled precious metals, and later lab-grown options — sold with the origin story attached to the stone. The name itself does double work, promising both sparkle and planet. What the traditional trade treated as an awkward question became their entire shop window.

It worked because the timing of hearts had changed: a generation that asked where its coffee and sneakers came from was never going to stop asking at the jewellery counter. Brilliant Earth grew from a San Francisco showroom into a publicly listed company, and the incumbents scrambled to add their own traceability pages. That is the mark of a story well aimed — when your competitors are forced to answer the question you taught customers to ask.

Why this story works
Primary driver: Oxytocin — love without a shadow

This is values storytelling with perfect product-emotion fit: an engagement ring is already a story object, so a shadow over its origin poisons the very thing being bought. By resolving that dissonance, Brilliant Earth lets the purchase say 'our love harms no one' — oxytocin, clean through. Strategically, it shows the power of institutionalizing a question: teach the market to ask it, and be the only one with a ready answer.

Steal this for your own storytelling
  • Find the question your industry hopes customers never ask — then build your brand as its answer.
  • Attach the origin story to the product itself; provenance is narrative customers can retell.
  • Align your story with what the purchase means emotionally, not just what the product does.
← ByteDance All 30 stories Forever 21 →

Your company has a story like this. Let’s find it.

David’s business storytelling keynotes teach your leaders and sales teams to find, shape and deliver stories like these — with the science to back it up.

Book a business storytelling keynote